Reviews Pepperoni Bill's Pizzeria

4
TT Hoover
+4
The food is great. Pictured is the chicken bacon ranch pizza, which is ok. But the real winner for me is the BLT Insalata pizza. It is my new favorite pizza, and will quite possibly be the only thing I order from here on out! They don't skimp on the bacon, and it balances out the salad on top.
5
Fran Keal
+5
Their pizza is the best but they consistently close for no apparent reason. This has been going on since before the pandemic. Tried to go there at 5 pm on Saturday and they were closed. We absolutely cannot rely on them to be open. It’s no way to run a business. You cannot possibly have this many “emergencies”.
4
Betty K
+4
I’m grateful that they have a vegan cheese option. And even more grateful that they don’t up-charge for it, like a lot of restaurants do. We’ve eaten here three times and it is consistently good. Do not be in a hurry because the service is a little slow, but we always enjoy our food from here. We’ll be back!
5
Vinnie Iuppa
+5
Truly a great pizza place. I had their meatballs and garlic bread to start and the meatballs were large and flavorful with a really nice and light consistency. I followed up with a calzone that had some of the best ground beef I've ever had at pizza place, so often ground beef for a pizza is tough and bland but this was great. Everything was made to order exactly as we requested and the server was quick and attentive. I would absolutely recommend a visit.
5
Jeff Baker
+5
We like to try different pizza shops when traveling and this was hands down one of the best we have came across. This isn't your typical box Hut pizza. Locally owned pizza shops are much more fun and good. I believe it is all thin crust pizzas. It was delicious we stuffed our selves.
5
Joshua Spurgeon
+5
The best pizza and Italian sandwiches ever (in my own opinion, anyway). I will drive out of my way to eat here. The quality keeps going up and up and up. Excellent service and valued customer experience. Really cool atmosphere.
5
Nancy
+5
We had a large deluxe pizza. It was excellent. This was our first time in the new dining addition. Kids will love that they have a robot, named Crash, who delivers the pizza to the table. What fun!
5
Kris Hand
+5
The pizza is delish here. I always seem to have the two same servers and both girls are amazingly polite and efficient. I’ve heard negative reviews from family and friends who refuse to go here because of bad service but there’s no way they had the same servers that I had. I’m super boring and order plain cheese pizza but my husband ordered the gyro pizza and my friend ordered the salad pizza. I’ve also had the fried zucchini and cheese bread and everything is very good.
5
Ron Petersen
+5
This place is amazing! The pizza is the best at the Lake. Great prices, fresh ingredients, lovely staff. The salad bar is a great deal. Especially if you share. Homemade salad dressings. Really creative and classic pizzas. Good for takeout too.
5
Robert S
+5
The Top Nachos pizza was delicious and H.U.G.E. The service was excellent, I️ am pretty sure every time a waitress walked by we were asked if everything was alright or topped off our water glasses. All of the staff seemed to enjoy working here. Do not forget to check out the cool art on the pizza boxes.
5
Murrays Florist
+5
Ordered the S.O.B., Hand-tossed! Fantastic! Ingredients tastes fresh. Pizza crust was, in our opinion, perfectly bubbly, crispy on the edge but soft on inside! We feel it is the best pizza we have ever had! Next time we are in the area, Pepperoni Bill’s is on our list! See you in October!
5
Abigail James
+5
Went there a couple days ago with my two kids while we were down there for vacation. My daughter was disappointed that we were going home before Friday (which is our normal Friday pizza movie night). She was hoping to enjoy some more pizza from here.
5
nightsky03
+5
It's a pizza place. Good salad bar. Thin crust and hand tossed. There is also a gluten free cauliflower crust option. Lots of specialities. Picture is the 10 inch. Perfect for 1 adult.
5
Abbie Jones
+5
The gluten free with vegan cheese was amazing. My hubby got the chicken bacon ranch and said it was awesome. Service was 5 stars!! I soooo recommend this place.
5
Robby Wilson
+5
We moved here almost 8 months ago. How has it taken me this long to discover this place? It's not like I don't drive by it daily. Honestly, I was starting to get the impression that good pizza did not exist at the lake. We moved from the NW Suburbs of Chicago where pizza is practically it's own food group, so it was disheartening to say the least to not be able to score a quality pie. That changed this week, as this place knows how to do it right. I am not easily impressed and I was pretty blown away by the freshness of the toppings, the delicious crust, and the tanginess of the sauce. Just. Friggin. Yum. Do note that you will pay more than average for a pie here, but after you take that first bite you will know where that extra cash is going. I opted for sliced meatballs as an option on mine in place of more traditional meat offerings, and that was sure a good call. I will definitely be going that route again. I probably should have taken some pictures but I pretty much attacked it as soon as we got it home, so no dice there. I will try to take one on subsequent visits. I opted for carryout, but the interior looks nice and would make for a good night out option with my fam also I suspect. If you are in or around this area and are looking for a good pizza, this place is a no-brainer. Now I just need to try that RJ's place down the street that is so packed it looks like they are giving away free beer and lap dances every time I drive by.
5
kim fischer
+5
Very good pizza You will love the robot that delivers to your table