Wally's Cafe And Pizzeria

My pizza was really good, but I had just cheese. My husband had pepperoni, peppers and onions and wasn't as happy. He said the peppers/onions were mushy more like what you'd use on a sub rather than fresh. So while it was OK for him he would like to try something else before making his ultimate decision. Overall the workers were super friendly, we will be ordering again and I would recommend.

I really wanted some late night pizza. I can be picky with pizza (some make the sauce too sweet). Wally’s has a nice balanced sauce with a slight sweet but the other herbs come through well. The pizza crust was a good thickness and not very thin. I really liked it. I’m not from Buffalo, so I am not a blue cheese fanatic and in fact I dislike the taste. However, Wally’s makes some really good blue cheese! It’s really creamy and not too strong. Will get again!

I LOVED Wally’s pizza so so much. Recently I ordered a personal pizza and it was very thin and in a square not typical personal. So yea it was good but didn’t have that good crust to top it off. I also just ordered 2 subs today, never ordered their subs and wanted to try. Steak hoagie was very dry and not even added cheese they called back to ask for (asked for Swiss added originally then called back and agreed to provolone) then the chicken finger was not hot, as asked for, and added cheese to that one. Maybe a mix up ? Wally’s used to be my favorite pizza place but now it’s not even an option.

My husband and I were so excited to try the deep dish pizza after seeing this place come up so many times in our search on food delivery service apps. Unfortunately, we will not be returning customers. Our deep dish pizza looked and smelled amazing but was incredibly undercooked. We threw it in the oven to try and finish it off but it literally took so much time and heat it started to burn. Stunk up the house something fierce, and guess what? The dough in the middle was still not cooked. Absolutely ridiculous. We should not have had to do anything with the pie to begin with! For a place that touts having Buffalo Deep Dish you would think they would know how to properly bake a thick pizza dough and not serve up a gummy, undercooked, unsafe pie!

Heard so many different options on Wally's, so I will be venturing over to the establishment to see for myself. FishFrys are said to be phenomenal. Chicken Wings along with chicken dinners were of most concern, due to not being made correctly. My earnest opinion why does anyone spend 50 dollars at a restaurant? You can grab a quick burger or 2 and fry it at home . Try a small item first.

Wally's is fantastic!! We had a recent order that a sub was forgotten. They went above and beyond and brought my sub to my door in a matter of minutes. They also asked what they could do to make it right. I wasn't worried as mistakes happen. But they insisted and offered a yummy treat. Thank you Wally's!!