The best bagel I have had in years, and likely the best bagel in NYC right now. Crust was thin and crisp, crumb beautiful, and the whole bagel was covered in everything seasoning. Burnt scallion cream cheese was delicious. I went half an hour out of my way to come by and it was absolutely worth it.
Pizza and cocktails were both delicious. Staff was really friendly but it was a little disappointing that no mention of the hot oil or honey were made. The place also gets super busy. Would love a beef option. All of their meat option is pork.
Overall definitely worth it to try it and I would go ba
This place is a very nice surprise. The Coney Island and the New Haven pies were ridiculously good. The bartender and waiter were super friendly and attentive. This place is worth traveling for!
Great tasting pizza. The pizza has good flavor and crisp. The staff is friendly and attentive. Some of the best tasting pizza in Brooklyn.
Loved the pizza and the place. It’s so cozy that from outside it seemed it was closed until I went for closer inspection.
Amazing neighborhood pizza and bar. Their pizza combinations are a must try and they have great cocktails to go with it. Must try to dip the crust in their homemade chili oil. Fire 🔥!
Hands down, this is by far the best and my favorite pizza in NYC. If you like a very tasty (on the thicker side) crust, delicious sauce (on the sweet side- as it should be!) and amazing delicious toppings, this is your spot. I am a huge pizza fan and have tired many pizza joints around the city, and
Outstanding!!! Get the Cesar salad with the dreamiest croutons you’ll ever taste. I cannot recommend the pizza or cocktails enough. A gem!
First timers to Wheated. On par with all the elite New York shops, but best customer service experience we've had at any of the sit down pizzerias - bartender and waiter could not have been more welcoming. We ordered 4 different pies and each was cooked perfectly. Fantastic cocktails. Can't wait to
Really really great crisp on these pizzas, the NY style pie had the cheese under the sauce and it really worked perfect keeping the entire pie crispy. delicious all around and really awesome staff as well- great vibe
An awesome whiskey bar that happens to serve great pizza as well, with friendly service and a cozy atmosphere to boot.
I first came to Wheated in March 2020 and struck a deal for some whiskey they were selling to raise money to pay staff. I'm happy I got it, happy to support their good cause at the
Ok. Let's talk about Wheated. It was good before COVID. Somehow, post COVID has gotten phenomenal.
It's a small space that doesn't open until 5pm, but best believe you should show up at 4:45p to get a seat cuz they're at capacity by 5:08. The Pizza is THAT good. Granted, it's a tad expensive. But
Easily Top 3 pizza I’ve ever had and it honestly might be #1. This is very legit pie and worth making the journey to get it.
ordered Bensonhurst for take away. added mushrooms on half of the pizza it was super delicious. can not stop thinking about this pizza. highly recommend
This place is a real treat! Our usual order is the pineapple pie on their menu and we add bacon, but we had their new pie, the Dumbo, and it was amazing. Going to be hard deciding which one to order next time. We always get one of their cocktails too. Really miss sitting at the bar at this place but
It’s two exceptional places in one: easily Oke of the best cocktail bars AND one of he best pizza places anywhere! The extensive and sharply varied whiskey collection is a brilliant surprise! Friendly staff makes this unassuming restaurant so additionally special!
East Williamsburg pizza pie 29$total, charred crust , very crispy, cheese and mushrooms were very delicious. 9/10
Best pepperoni pizza!
The Ice cream in the sundae is not too sweet, good combination with the sweet brownie. The cherry so sweet! Amazing!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes