Review Coals - Bronxville

Heard about this place due to an IPA I fell in love with that the owner brews at his brewery named Run & Hide brewery (soon to open) in Port Chester, NY. Quickly decided I had to stop by and we were blown away by the pizza and wings here. Grilled, crunchy thin crust, fresh quality ingredients. A Delicious pizza!! With a SOLID craft beer menu! Great service and attentive staff!

We came here for dinner on a Friday. The waitstaff was pleasant but could be more attentive. The food came out promptly and was tasty. The pizza is a super thin crust, almost like a tortilla (another reviewer said this as well). It is a big pie and can easily be shared by two people. Overall, we had a nice evening and enjoyed the food here.

Tried this place out on a Saturday afternoon. Quaint decor. Interesting menu options. I had their "spicy" grilled buffalo wings and their cheeseburger. The wings were made perfectly. The right amount of crisp on the edges, and the sauce was amazing. However, there was no "spicy" to the wings. Great flavor and highly recommended, but don't get your hopes up for any spiciness. The burger (which I later found out won Westchester Magazine's 2015 Burger and Beer Blast Best Burger in Westchester award) was quite plain and forgetful. Either the recipe changed in the last five years, or I ate it with less toppings than I should've (though a Best Burger winner should be judged on their beef and seasoning, not toppings). Know Before You Go: their kitchen closes for an hour (3:30pm-4:30pm). I'd definitely go again, just to give the burger another chance.

Margherita pizza is excellently done. But what really shines is THE WINGS! they do something to finish them (broiled in oven)? That gives them a smoky, flame-kissed flavor that mimics them being grilled.

The place has a bar vibe but food is everything but not bar food. Pizza is the best I had In New York, burgers are pretty good, grilled wings we had for an appetizers with honey rosemary are amazing. Unfortunately the place is getting closed in a few weeks so if you haven't been over there go while it's still there.

Always delicious every time. Pure Bliss pie is my favorite and the rosemary wings and brussel sprouts appetizers are tasty! Give this place a try you won’t regret it!!!

Fantastic Maple Rosemary Wings and every pizza is delicious (unique thin crust). Great customer service, got our food very quick. Docked one star for recent raised prices.

Amazing food and great beer selection This is one of our go to places. The pizza is super thin yet not to crispy. We always get the margarita or the rustic. They also have one of the best wings in town. While they have 2 flavors I recommend doing 50/50 which they will do upon request. In addition we were pleasantly surprised with their beer selection. They have a great dining area and out door seating. We often end up eating at the bar which is always a great experience. My only issue with them is I wish they delivered! Not a major issue as we still order and pick up.

A bit pricier, but certainly some of the best pizza in the area. The pizza is thin, so if you are ordering delivery, or even take out, it may be a bit cold. Additionally, it can be difficult calling in to order during certain times as well. If you are willing to deal with those few issues however, they make an excellent pizza. Higher quality ingredients, a great sauce, and that coal fired taste set it apart and above much of the competition.

Xlnt thin crust pizza! Quality ingredients and tasty flavors. Wings were delicious. Beers on tap were great! Servers looked annoyed but we're actually quite nice. Thumbs up!

I LOVE this spot. Used to spend a lot of time here when it was Port Chester. I was nervous there would be some difference in this new location, but it has not skipped a beat at all. This place has great pizza, an amazing burger, and out of control wings. Great beer, great service, and a great atmosphere. Everyone should eat here.

Grilled pizza is the best and this is one of the few places to get it!

Really, really good hand tossed, artisan-style, grilled pizza. Plan to share unless your super hungry because one pizza is the size of a large serving platter. Had a very good server who was prompt with refills and knowledgeable about the menu. Overall was really impressed with the whole experience. Would definitely recommend!

Really cozy feel. Even though it looks like a typical bar at first when walk in, it's great for families. Decent size eating area in the back. Neighborhood is a small town feel. Good variety of specialty pizzas and burgers. Great beer selection as well.