Teresa's Italian Ices, Ice-cream & Cafe

Once inside, I find myself tasting all the treats in this veritable abbondanza of pastries, cookies, cakes and, of course, Teresa’s special Italian Ices. I’m especially partial to the Lilly with Nuts. It a uniquely New York flavor that Teresa captures so well. Although I’m not from the neighborhood, it certainly worth the trip. During one visit, I was fortunately confronted by a warm tray of freshly baked miniature sfogliatella sitting in parchment paper. I can still relish the experience. Whether it’s ices or baked goods, one is never overwhelmed by the note of sweetness, it rather the distinct flavor of the treat that shines through. You can’t go wrong here.

Tiny little bakery but a ton of flavor and love comes out of this place! Everything is fresh home made from the fresh filled cannoli to the chocolate hearts filled with things like peanut butter Nutella raspberry and all the gelato I wanted to buy one of everything but I will definitely be back to eventually try everything great spot!

Teresa’s can surprise you with many things. First the place is so beautiful and cute and makes you feel like you just want to buy all the items you feel welcome. Second the attention is great the staff is attentive to the customers. And third from the ice cream till the rainbow cookies the flavor is no too sweet not simple is perfect… this place is one of my faves to get my sweets treats

Went back today for the first time since the pandemic hit. Again, Teresa was so sweet. Her St. Joseph’s pastry and cappuccino were delicious. Also bringing home more treats. Thank you, again! First Review: Teresa and her daughter could not be any sweeter to me and my husband on our first visit there yesterday. Her Italian ices and pastries were “Excellent”! Just walking in to her cute store brought me back to my childhood in Brooklyn. Will definitely be going back.