If you are looking for true authentic Italian food this is the place for you!
Stopped in after a long day of shopping and had to wait a little but boy was it worth it! I had the Baked Rigatoni and it was absolutely one of the best dishes I have ever had. I have reviewed and ate many dishes but this was one of the best.
The sauce was fresh and had deep flavors, the Ricotta was house made and had great cheesiness. The whole dish was incredible everything we had was fresh and flavorful.
Would 100% recommend to anyone looking for a Authentic Italian food.
Once again, PaPa GeGe's serves up awesome food! The sausage, spinach and olives calzone I enjoyed for dinner this evening was amazingly delicious!
Awesome food! Great service! Papa GeGe's Italian Villa has the best pizza in the Mahoning Valley! The White Supreme Pizza is delicious!
This was our first time here. I have been hearing great comments. They are spot on. The food was hot and fresh, the portions are crazy large.
The cavatelli has Diablo sauce and I got a piece of sausage it was very good, my husband got the chicken parm. Said it was fantastic. The stuffed hot peppers were ok, not something I would order again but hats off to the staff, great job and great food. Kennedy was very helpful in ordering and came and chatted with us for a minute
First time here had calzone it was great I will make it back to try other menu items.
I haven't had food from PaPa GeGe's in quite a while but was in the mood for it and wanted to share with a friend.
It tasted exactly like it did a few years back when I first ordered it. Very consistent!
Always have been blown away by the food quality here. Truly an underrated Italian restaurant in the Mahoning Valley that deserves waaay more credit, especially over some of these other "Italian" restaurants in Boardman. True Italian cooking here!
Also always enjoyed seeing the owner Eugene cooking and answering the phone. Means a lot to me when he calls you by your first name from the caller ID. To me, that's personalized service and I appreciate that. Not only that but his dedication to excellence and professionalism. True passion from this owner! Thank you Eugene for another wonderful experience at your restaurant!
This restaurant is a hidden gem I’ve always passed it and never stopped until today, I must say these were the best stuffed shells I had in a while . The service was great and the host was very attentive. You must try this place you won’t be disappointed 😊
We did catering for my mom’s bdays. The chicken was fantastic! The salad dressing and pasta were on my mind for days! Everyone raved about the food! Thank you so much!
Every meal I've had here, whether dine in or take out, has been so fantastic! The sauces are amazing, so it's not easy choosing which one to have. The large portions ensure that no one goes away hungry. If you haven't tried the food here, DO IT. YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED!
My 12 year old found this place. She loves pizza and thought she wanted to try this place when we past it to go to Barnes and Noble. Anyways, glad she did! I love meat pizzas and the carnivore is my favorite. We’ve gone back 3 times now. My first time I thought the price was high, until I saw the size of the slice. I think you get even MORE when you order the full pizza (instead of by the slice) but either way the slices are massive.
My wife picked up the pizza 🍕 this time and she said she told the older Gentleman how much we loved the pizza and he was happy!! So I decided to leave this review as well. 100% recommend
Fantastic food. This is our 3rd time and its delicious. The stuffed hot peppers and calamari 🥰
The ravioli and three different pasta dishes we've orderd are fantastic. Small place but big food
I ordered a cannoli. The ensuing battle between my mind & stomach following the first bite was tumultuous for a split second. The central logic department wanted to slowly enjoy the delicious delicacy; the devouring organ that actually is in control consumed the luxurious treat in a shorter amount of time than it took to write this review. Purely exquisite
Salad and garlic knots are very delicious. I ordered the chicken Parmigiano dinner, and my husband custome made a calzone. Crust is amazing. Staff very friendly.
1st time here after moving to the area a year ago per my daughters request. It was amazing!! Pepperoni roll was hot and crispy and the marinara dipping sauce was on point! Also got wings (sorry for no picture) but were also bomb! Plus to add to the ambiance they play the best Italian music 😉 Our new favorite lunch spot!
Awesome food that is reasonably priced! We tried a number of dishes, and they all were great. Loved the garlic knots with cheese and Ge Ge rolls with sausage and peppers. Definately recommend stopping here - it is set back off the main road - look for the Italian colored awning.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes