Sluurpy > Restaurants in Bloomington > Goodfellas Pizzeria

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Bloomington - Photo album

Great pizza! They gave out huge slices and a giant bread stick all for a cheap price. Food was good, restaurant was nice. I especially liked the historical photos they had on the wall from different time periods.

Let me start by saying that the theme is so fun! The decor is sleek.The food, service, and cleanliness were all great. We got greeted right in the door. So I gave it four stars NOT because of any of that, but while waiting for our food a explicit song came on the speaker being played while a child w

Really good vibes here; the employees are always really kind. Pizza available almost all day and always tastes good and fresh. I love how thin and crunchy the crust is. They even made me a pizza with no cheese since I have dairy sensitivities so that was cool. Slices are really big and filling. Brea

[UPDATED] Now that they've been open for a few weeks we gave them another try. Food is much improved. Perfectly acceptable lunchtime pizza. Sauce is still on the bland side, but crust is quite good, and cheese and toppings are reasonably flavorful. The lunch special (big slice, side, and drink for

This is my new favorite pizza spot in Bloomington. For one, the lunch special is incredibly cheap. I honestly could not believe I got as much food as I did for $6. The pizza itself has a crispy crust underneath, and a softer dough texture when you bite into it. The bread sticks are massive, and have

Very tasty pizza. As a NJ native, it was refreshing to find a place in Bloomington that makes good NY-style pizza. It seems like all of the other local places I have tried around here opt for a drier crust with a super low tomato sauce:cheese ratio, focusing more on interesting toppings than on the

Amazing pizza!!! One of the best NY style pizza joints I've found! The service was really good as well!

I’ve been to the one in Indianapolis and loved it, so I was eager to try the new Bloomington location. I was not disappointed. Super friendly staff, the food was fresh, and tasted great. Looking forward to returning again soon!