So good! I haven't had pizza this great since I lived in Chicago. Friendly, casual, clean place. A 10 inch stuffed Hawaiian pizza was more than enough for me and my boyfriend, plus leftovers to take home. They were welcoming even though we got there 20 minutes before they closed at 9:00. It takes 35-40 minutes for stuffed pizza, that's the way it is in Chicago too. Sauce made in house, delicious crust (and they have whole wheat!), SO much cheese... I wish they used fresh pineapple but that's the only thing I can think of that could be better. Will definitely be back!
First visit and will definitely return!!! We ordered the Beachum Chicago Style Pizza. It had pepperoni, bacon, green bell peppers, onions and fresh jalapenos. The sauce was wonderful and so flavorful! A delicious pizza! Great casual atmosphere and friendly staff. Very clean place and they have it together! Thanks Tortugas for a fun Friday dinner!
Chicago style pizza is a treat not everyone can pull off and you won't find at every pizza place. Despite it's name they are a delicious deep dish pizza. The crust was thin and crispy, the veggies weren't over cooked, the sauce a nice flavor. I would recommend a few recipe Tweeks. But worth the cook time. Met the family owners and they are so nice. This is a business that deserves your support you won't be disappointed and hope staffing shortages won't close it down
I’m originally from Illinois and we are known for deep dish pizza. Since moving here we have been on the search for great pizza that isn’t Pizza Hut or dominoes. We have found it! Loved the deep dish and the thin crust. We won’t go to any other pizza place again in Bham.
We also tried the homemade pumpkin cheesecake and it was so yummy. Recommended by a nice man who frequents Tortugas on a regular basis. The staff are very friendly.
Tortugas is one of the best deep dishes you can find, not just in Birmingham, but anywhere. I've had Lou Malnati's and Gino's East and Giordano's (all Chicago-based deep dish eateries), and Tortugas holds their own against those titans. As an avid deep dish fan this is my go-to place in Birmingham for pizza. I usually get the Carne Special (photo) as a carry-out. As with all deep dish it takes 45-60 minutes from when you order to when it's ready. But I can guarantee you that it's WORTH it!!! We are so lucky to have such amazing deep dish here down south.
Awesome pizza! Got the deep dish and thin crust. Best Chicago style pizza I have ever had. Beer selection was good as well. Owner on site and came by our table to check on us. Service was great!
They did an amazing job with their pizza. Best Chicago style pizza I've had outside of Chicago! It felt like I was having a pizza outside of Wrigley Field. Very nice and welcoming staff with a very clean and enjoyable atmosphere.
Best pizza in Birmingham hands down. The owner, Matt, is just a top notch person. I am originally from Chicago and I discovered his parents location in Hoover several years ago and was so excited when they opened a downtown location. I would crawl ten miles on pins and needles just to watch someone eat this pizza. Side note, the lasagna is on point too.
Grab an incredibly delicious Chicago style pie before heading over to a Barron's game. Very friendly staff!
I’m originally from Chicago and I was desperately trying to find a good pizza. This place surpassed my expectations. Reminds me of home. The pizza is so good.The service was amazing. I’m so happy I finally found a stop.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Birmingham
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes