Delicious! I walk by this place all the time while walking pups. I was so happy to finally try a medium pizza with veggies... sssoooOOoooooo good. � I will be back. Thanks so much Anthony's!
Delicious pizza! I feel like a found a hidden treasure with this place! Staff is friendly and will do what they can to make sure you are satisfied.. Definitely a 10/10
Anthony's has quick service (friendly staff!), and our delicious pizza arrived steaming hot with sausage and onion perfectly arranged on a secret recipe dough with Grande cheese. One of our top two places to eat pizza. We drove 60 miles to get there and it was worth it. This is family owned/operated- not a franchise. You can taste the difference! 5+ stars!!!
They have the best buffalo chicken pizza with ranch on it the meatball subs are to die for the stromboli is good too the crew is nice they treat you like family
I found this gem hidden in the great town of Bexley; I was greeted with a smile and a hello, then I had the pizza, AWESOME, having tried a few other so called New York style pies in town, this is authentic quality and goodness. Be sure to stop in and say Hi to Martee and grab a slice or a whole. best NY pizza in CBus
I love the pizza and my husband loves the Italian sub. I have to eat here every time I visit Columbus!
As a native New Yorker who has had it with so called "New York" style pizza in Columbus, I have finally found the real deal. Awesome. Fuggedabowdit!
Great Pizza!!! My son and I enjoyed our pizza and defiantly will return
Small pizza shop in Bexley, with a big delicious pizza taste. Anthony’s Pizzeria’s pizzas are delicious and amazingly flavorful. Their sauce and cheese compliments any pizza toppings you add. It was reminiscent of a New York style pizza and taste. Limited seating inside and their is outdoor seating as well. Parking is also limited. Nice and friendly staff. Decent prices.
If your a fan of New York style pizza 🍕 😋... Then Anthony's is the place for you. It's a casual small pizza shop on the campus of Capital University next to the gym. After 8 p.m. the shop offers half price on individual slices. The pizza is delicious. Try Anthony's
I wanted to try a Detroit style pizza and this place was recommended by other pizza connoisseurs. We placed our order online and drove across town to pick it up. We got there a little bit ahead of our pick up time but it was ready on time according to our pick window. We were so hungry and wanted to try it fresh that we ate the first slice in the car. We got the Cadillac Detroit style and it was delicious. It had a generous amount of meat and cheese, crispy edges and a mild not overly sweet sauce. The crust was pretty dense and not what we expected. It had almost a biscuit like texture but it was still very tasty and we loved the buttery crusty corners. We will be back and look forward to trying other styles and combinations. No regrets on the burnt roof of my mouth
Pizza is really great. Sometimes. Sometimes not. The inconsistency is sometimes upsetting but all in all great pizza. You can get it by the slice. Their daily specials are rage about. I love their pepperoni. Nice and greasy and it cups and crisps. The salad was huge too. Lossa good stuff innit. Good prices too.
Ordered delivery from an app, and the Detroit style meat pizza was spot on. Also got a meatball sub, and it easily is one of the better meatball subs I've had.
I can't say its gourmet, but if you want solid cheap food, it won't get better than this.
I really enjoyed the pizza at Anthony’s Pizzeria. My wife got a gift certificate from Groupon so we thought we would try it out after driving up to Columbus from Ross County for Doctor appointments. My wife, son and I got the bbq chicken pizza which was a sauceless pizza due my son not able to handle pizza sauce. The pizza was amazing and then they had a special sauce you can pour on the pizza that adds a little zing as well. We got garlic knots as an appetizer and that was delicious as well! I wish they had a pre-baked pizza that I can take home and bake in the oven if I wasn’t up there during meal time. They do offer variety of Slice pizza for $2.99 and Capital Students get a free drink with a slice.
You know, having a close by place for slices is the best, right? And for it to be New York thin with all fresh ingredients, friendly peeps behind the counter, a five minute walk(for us), ring us up! We saw plenty of foot traffic while we munched our slices outside, we’ll be back.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes