Sluurpy > Restaurants in Bethany > Papa Angelo's Pizzeria

Papa Angelo's Pizzeria - Bethany - Photo album

A great local favorite. Thinner pizza crust with a cracker like texture and overall reminiscent to say Sabarros. The ingredients always taste fresh. Vegan cheese available if you’re into that. Odd hours of operation thanks to Covid-19 I’m sure. Stop in during the week for a great lunch special. Big

Pizza by the slice, salads, and more. This pizza cafe is quite large, and has pizza made to order that is worth a visit due to its deliciousness. Some of the best New York-esque pizza in OKC/Bethany area. Food: Thin, foldable, chewy crust with great cheese blend flavor and traditional pizza topp

Pricey but delicious. We discovered they have VEGAN CHEESE after we ordered. The garlic knots were great and their habanero sauce was AMAZING! We will be back for more!

Great NY style pizza. Some of the best in the OKC area, maybe my favorite.

Great Pizza! Easy online ordering and delivery! Garlic knots are also delicious.

You'd have to go to Brooklyn for a better pie! Quaint old world pizzeria! Get a 20" pepperoni. They have red paper flakes, parmigian cheese, oregano, garlic powder, salt and pepper on the table. Who does that? Papa Angelo does!

We made an order and paid for it, including a generous anticipatory tip and sat down to wait for our pizza. After 10 minutes the host came to our table and said that she apologized that they had run out of the primary topping ingredient. I understood and said I’d better just get the money back and m

If you’re looking for New York style pizza, look no further than Papa Angelo’s. We always enjoy what we order; the food is always very fresh and delicious. The atmosphere is a fun tribute to NYC.