Old Town Amish Store

They had a good selection of goods but was very rude. We got there on a Saturday about 4:50 pm. They did not close till 6:00 pm. It wasn't even 5 o'clock yet. My brother in-law and Sister walked over to the Deli to check it out. As soon as they walked up to the Deli an Employee that was sweeping dropped the broom and ran to turn off the lights behind the deli. My sister then spoke up about getting something from the deli. The employee just walked off and said, "Sorry, the deli just closed." My brother-in-law and sister just walked out. They did not look at anything else because of the way the employee acted. My wife asked for half of a pumpkin role and the employee huffed and acted upset that she had to get it for us. I work in customer service and I understand wanting to get out as fast as you can but when you close at 6 you closes at 6. Horrible customer service. I would give it a one star but it did have some good local stuff there. The pumpkin role was really good also.

Love, love, love this place! Every jam, jelly and pickled vegetable you can imagine. Wide variety of candies, baked goods, too, and a full function deli! The Amish chicken salad is some of the best I've ever eaten. There's also a large flower shop outside with fresh melons and citrus ... not sure if it's affiliated with the store or not, but nice people there, as well. Great staff, polite and helpful. If you're passing through Berea, stop and give this place a try, you will definitely NOT be disappointed!

Wonderful food and products! From the first time my husband and son had a deli meal from there, a year ago, they did nothing but talk about it after. I myself finally got to see what the big deal was, and no, they were not exaggerating. Good, filling food (important to someone having to feed a 17 yr old in the throes of a growth spurt), the products for sale, from the jams to the hope chests *drooling*, they have you covered for Kentucky Proud items of quality. The staff was quite sweet and helpful. Most definitely will be a favored spot from now on!

I give the Amish store one stars because the staff are very unfriendly. The sandwich’s are really good but I have never experienced such rudeness in my life! You would think we were a big crowd of obnoxious people the way they treated us. I worked in customer service so I know rough days are a thing but the lady at the register today just threw me my receipt and was very short as if I was aggravating her that I was there. I went there for a family brunch, I will not be back.