Review Pizza Pirate - Benicia

Slow place. Would of expected more out of the raviolis and bread twists with soda we got for around $30. Food is not too bad. Clean place though. Could be better. By the ways what up with this all genders bathroom sign and the third person?

For $35 I expected some kind of greens on a plate not a small soup bowl. The ravioli looks empty inside. The silverware is limp plastic. It took about 45 minutes to get an order of just two items. Aaarg matey, it's all theme but no dream.

Love the pizza here, it's always delicious and fills me up. This is my second time here, and it's just like I remember it. I hope to enjoy it for many more years. Thank You for the amazing Pizza

I've always enjoyed the food at Pizza Pirate and they have a fair selection of beer. On weekends and often in the summer, it gets busy and very loud with all the kids who love going there for the games and freedom to run around. It's an institution in Benicia. Their salad bar is gone because of Covid, but their pizza is still great.

Very best, fresh pizza between Los Angeles and the North Bay area. Been eating there for almost 20 years! And, I live in Bakersfield! Super family friendly, too......I drive 280 miles for "Pirate Pizza".....in Benicia! Tell them, " Larry from Bakersfield sent me!"

Had a really great time Jessica the manager is really sweet! It definitely was the best pizza I've ever had and the breadsticks and the wings oh my God so delicious I definitely highly recommend this place

Pizza Pirate has saved me and my husband many times over the last few years with hot, fresh pasta, kid-friendly options, and so many delicious garlic twists. Sometimes it was when we couldn’t find the energy to cook at home so did a quick call in and pick up, and sometimes it’s because we had a craving to eat out, and each time, we’ve had a great experience and meal! When it was time to help plan my daughter’s end of year school party, pizza was an easy choice for feeding 100 first graders! I contacted Pat at Pizza Pirate a couple weeks before the last day of school to see if Pizza Pirate could accommodate a big order, have them ready before they officially opened, and make sure pizzas were double-cut to limit precious wasted pizza. Not only did Pat respond to each and every email with lightning speed time to accommodate us, he generously gave us the pizzas half off to help maximize our budget for the party and kids. Pizza Pirate is the only place in town my kids love and we’ll be making sure we support them all summer long. After the party, my daughter thanked me for coordinating and exclaimed, I ate four pieces, which is a BIG win for my usually picky eater. Thanks to Pat and the Pizza Pirate team for helping us close the school year right!

Love the pizza but seriously a surcharge for using a card to pay? This is how you tell customes you can charge them whatever and too bad if you don't like it. Surcharge was only 1.81 but I did buy 60 bucks worth of food. Napoli pizza is closer so I think that is where we need to go from now on and the food is just as good if not better. Sorry pirate but this was not cool and I have been buying from there since the 80s

I like the walk the plank pizza and they have the best ranch for dipping bread sticks! Good place for family night out for pizza. Service is always friendly.