Vicario's Pizza - Bellefontaine - Photo album

This was our first time here since the move. We decided to get hamburgers and fries and shared an order if mushrooms. We also ordered a pizza and pasta to go for our children. We were hesitant to order hamburgers from a pizza place but we are so glad we did. They were hands down one of the best burg

It really doesn't get better than this. All time favorite pizza place. Plus there's something for everyone. New location is super nice! This the one place I wanted to eat after 5 weeks in California (California doesn't have good pizza. I left reviews lol) that's how good it is kids.

Not a bad place… My wife and I went this weekend to pick up some pizza and subs to celebrate my birthday…. I thought the pizza was pretty good; my wife didn’t like it.. We both were not impressed with the subs.. Good choices in the bar section. I tried an amazing local beer while I was waiting… The

I had the large pepperoni pizza with the sweet sauce and the pizza was amazing as usual! I travel to Bellefontaine in order to get this pizza. It’s been a favorite since I was a child and still is now! Everyone should try this pizza!

This by far my favorite pizza place. I love their sweet sauce. Anytime I am in Bellefontaine, it is a must that I stop at Vicarios’ Pizza. Love the new location!

Horrible pizza. I have eaten here since 1990s when I was in nursing school. Have always loved there pizza but since the move not impressed, tonight we got a large pizza which is really an extra large. They have changed their cheese or something, it tasted horrible, we ate 5 pieces and threw it

Really the best pizza of all-time. I've prolly had over 100 pizzas in my life (different styles, places, frozen, fresh). Nothing beats that sweet sauce and crust!

Worst calzone I've ever had. Mostly iceberg lettuce chunks, raw unmelted cheese, uncooked tomatoes, 5 small meatballs and 5 slices of pepperoni, cracker consistency breading crust. Horrible. Alternative metal music was very unpleasant. One customer literally went around the restaurant and asked