American cuisine: the best places to taste it in Bayville

"I went to Sub World today for the first time since they have reopened because of the devastating fire they suffered which cause them to close down..."

Lisa Fisher

Jessica Geneski

Mill Creek Tavern

86/100 (1844 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

Accepts American Express

Free off-street parking

"The food and the environment at Mill Creek are both incredible! The staff is always super friendly and Rich, the owner, is often there greeting..."

Laura Cienkowski

"Sort ribs in Jaegerschnitzel sauce was amazing, perhaps my best meal here. Really nice go to neighborhood..."

Joan Essex

"Great food and great service - for couples and large groups. And I can’t say enough about the..."

Alan Miller

"The bartenders are the best especially Kathy Pirkl. The food is always excellent. Very comfortable and great..."

David Wright

"Excellent staff. Duck was crispy & delicious, sauce was perfect. Special seasonal salad was very flavorful. Everyone in our group had something..."

Trish Elizabeth Neill

"I have been to the Mill.Creek Tavern several times with my date & also with another couple. We like the place because of the atmosphere. I always..."

Frank Napoli

"First We ordered the fried calamari, loved the white sauce that came with it, it had a bite but not bad at all. Then my husband ordered the seafood..."

Celeste C Pacifico

"Wow the food was just amazing. Complete comfort food vibes.. everything made with love and..."

Sal Verdi

"This is a great little local spot. We always liked getting the chicken pot pie during the cold season. It is absolutely the best chicken pot pie you..."

James Kamerer

"We had a delicious dinner at Mill Creek Tavern. The service is fantastic and the atmosphere very friendly. We saw friends there and one was having a..."

Kay Charon

"Amazing seafood at this cozy little spot in Bayville. Our server Jeanne was so..."

Jerry George

"We were visiting family in Mill neck and choose Mill Creek Tavern because they have a very nice menu. I like that they print the daily specials with..."

Richard Schagrin

"Every time we go to Mill Creek we know we are going to have outstanding food and service. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming. Ginny and Vanessa..."

Mrs. Annamarie Mansueto

"We have eaten here many times as we live in town. This weekend was my Grandson’s Baptism. My Son and his Wife used the private room for a brunch,..."

Scott D

"Nice homey feel in the dining room. Welcoming atmosphere, and great attentive staff. We went for restaurant week and they had a great deal with a 3..."

Jeff Woo

"The food at Mill Creek is always delicious, and the atmosphere is..."

Amanda Romero

"This is a great local tavern with a variety of menu options that hits all your taste buds. Our group enjoyed each meal we had. The most impressive..."

Andrew Licata

"Delicious food. Always great portions. Close, convenient and delicious. Tonight we had the Buffalo spring rolls and blackened quesadilla, angus..."

Nicky Mazz

"Great restaurant for a quiet night out, where you can hear the people you are with. Good acoustics. More importantly great food at reasonable prices,..."

Thomas Hayes

"My wifes Angus sliders were hand made and cooked to a perfect MR. I had the special .. Lobster Ravioli with Shrimp and Asparagus in a pink sauce. The..."

chris simons

"Great food, wait staff friendly & knowledgeable. We had a wonderful..."

Susan Syty

"I have been here more than once , the food is outstanding! I have had a few different dishes including the beet salad. Everything is flavorful and..."

Phyllis

"The Cheeseburger Sliders, Mac n Cheese and Rigatoni Ala Vodka are all delicious! The portions are very generous and the prices are reasonable. Will..."

Daniel Shanle

The Crescent Beach Club

86/100 (1667 ratings)

"I got married at the Crescent Beach Club on August 3rd, 2018. I was originally going to Jamaica to get married but had to cancel my destination..."

Karine Gordon

"Probably the nicest view for cocktail hour and ceremony of all venues that i had pleasure to work at. Ballroom is also great and so is the food and..."

Krystian Fryzlewicz

"We are so pleased with the weddings that we've worked at the Crescent Beach Club, and we were blown away with how seamless every event was! The..."

Blair Applegate

"Enjoyed the most amazing time there! Attended a beautiful couples wedding! Every detail from start to finish was magical!! Felt like a destination..."

Carol M.

"Title: "A Magical Beachfront Wedding Experience at the Crescent Beach Club" Rating: ★★★★★ (5/5) Review: My experience at the Crescent..."

Digital Hassan

"I was invited out for a drink here, i decided to go and at first I was skeptical. Was supposed to go for 30 mins and that turned into 5..."

Geo Araque

"Very beautiful venue. Everything was set up with nice displays, especially the Mimosa and Bloody Mary bar. The staff were very quick, attentive, and..."

Daphne Urso

"Beautiful location with amazing views! One of my close friends got proposed here. Wonderful drinks &..."

Neha S

"Went for happy hour which was nice. The patio deck was really nice with a spectacular view of the Long Island..."

Jim Holland

"My wife and I had our wedding here back in April of 2022, needless to say we absolutely loved every single portion of the process with Crescent Beach..."

Sam Schwartz

"I got proposed at the Crescent beach club and it was so beautiful! Everything from the views, food, and service were amazing!..."

Joanne Kottathara

"Very beautiful and breathtaking views from either the beach level or the top level. You can't go wrong with either..."

Josue Polanco

"Beautiful place. There for a private party. Service was great. The patio had outdoor heating so was possible to be outside even in late October. The..."

Paula Roberts

"Attended a wedding here. Beautiful beach ceremony. Staff was courteous and helpful. The food was very good. Had a nice..."

J Bar

"I only had a limited time to be in this special place, where even at night the view for the beach through the windows was wonderful. Hope to have..."

Sfront

"We came for wedding and it was nice! The food was super good, the location was perfect and drinks were amazing. We felt so relax here. The waitress..."

Meredith

"We just had our wedding here on Thursday 9/7/23. Everyone was SO nice, helpful, genuine, and amazing from the day we booked the venue till the day we..."

Michelle Villongco

"My husband and I had the most incredible wedding we could have dreamed of at the crescent beach club. It was quite literally a fairytale or something..."

Ashley Raimo

"Tucked away in Bayville is a gem in the sand, The Crescent Beach Club. While many will choose this waterfront spot for a wedding, they are also..."

Jacqueline Vita

Ocean

83/100 (1957 ratings)

"This is a beautiful beachfront ocean view restaurant. Upon arrival you will have your car valet so you can enter right in. The food here was great..."

Lexi C

"I was looking for a nice place for lunch with my girlfriends. It such a beautiful restaurant inside and out. Food was good but could be better. But..."

Sonia Khana

"First time here and LOVE this place! Had lunch Sunday afternoon with my girlfriend and it was definitely the best weather this summer so far, could..."

Elizabeth Razukiewicz

"The food was very good! The atmosphere and view were great. It was a weekend evening and the place was packed, so the service got slammed. The staff..."

John Hatalovsky Jr

"The view and the food was wonderful! Our waitress Tory went above and beyond to make sure we had everything we needed and were happy. It was obvious..."

Toni Junjulas

"My girlfriends and I had an awesome experience dining at Ocean last week! Such a beautiful view of the Long Island sound and especially the sunset on..."

Net D

"The views are so worth coming here to dine and relax with friends. The food was great, service was a bit slow, but that could’ve been due to going..."

Yasmin Mohamed

"James is an excellent host and manager. He sought to every detail during our meal on the beautiful sunset deck. Definitely..."

cdortenzio79

"Amazing!!! We had an incredible dining experience at Ocean. Made a reservation but got there around 7 on a Friday. Got a nice seat outside and..."

Nicole Pellegrino

"View is fantastic. Food is average. Lobster roll and seafood pasta were okay. Clam chowder was meh. The strawberry shortbread was too sweet for us...."

Kershee J

"Everyone needs to go here at least one night during the Summer. It’s on the beach and the sunset view is amazing. When you post pictures everyone..."

darl514

"First time here and probably won’t return but not because I had terrible service but for the price, and the size of quantity of food don’t match...."

Jiovani Rivera

"BEST food and View! Had the Lobster Bake and Seafood special… SO delicious! Lobster was the BEST I have had in Years. Service is attentive and..."

Joan Geagan

"Our favorite Happy Hour!! Amazing apps & drinks. Lobster Sliders on toasted brioche or mussels is a must. Gorgeous views and atmosphere. James & Tori..."

Victoria Mihlstin

"View Is Amazing Relaxed Atmosphere Drinks Are Ok Food Is Good Service Was So..."

Jerimiah Wade

"It was a Saturday evening so it was very busy, service was a bit disappointing but it didn't ruin the experience completely... The food and..."

Dave’s World

The Bridge Cafe

"Very local go to spot offering excellent fresh breakfast and lunches to the Bayville area residents. Small kitchen turns out very nice dishes time..."

Andrew Ross

"It was Awesome!! Food was delicious and staff was Great!! Highly recommended for everyone! Can't wait to get back there!! Thumbs up all..."

Paulette Bilella

"Nice sunny place with good standard breakfast. Had the whole wheat pancakes, but the waffles looked good too. Would come here..."

Ashley Polikoff

"We periodically eat at the Bridge Cafe and always enjoy our visit. The food is great, the pro d is right, and the owner Bridget & her staff are..."

Frances Mcmahon

"Great neighborhood place. Good food and great service. Love coming..."

Joel Ainatchi

"Cozy little place. Perfect for a quick bite. Comfort food. Clean. Polite and professional..."

Lisa Maloney

"Love this place. Great food, nice place to sit with the fam. Bridgette is awesome. Very friendly..."

Nicholas Palumbo (Nick)

"A small, cozy little diner with some great cooking and an amazing wait staff. Definately stop by if you're in the..."

patrick cannon

"Very good food very friendly good family..."

Victor N

"Great diner food. Try the fresh crab..."

Kevin Dunlap

"Good food nice..."

Steven Keogh

""Three eggs (over-easy), homefries, whole wheat toast; with a side of orange juice. Delicious!..."

George Kourtalis

"Always a pleasure, friendly staff and good..."

Anne Zwirlein

"The BEST super food and service bar..."

Kevin Murray

"Great food ..great..."

Randy Rosner

"It's like being in Mayberry. Bridgette does a great job very sweet..."

Rich Cutler

"If you like poached eggs then this is the place for you! Nobody does it..."

Richard Armstrong

"always delicious... super service..."

rosanne nicole

"Delicious food with generous..."

Veronica Parrino

Oh What A Bagel

Wheelchair Accessible

"Place is awesome and the food is great highly recommend To..."

Judo Steve

"Stopped in yesterday while visiting family. Food was great! Hopefully next time I'll get in early enough to get the french toast..."

Timothy Scott Jr.

"Great place, great bagels...been going since we moved here in..."

Darrin Wittson

"My wife's family owns this business, very professional and the bagels are amazing . Love the strawberry bagel with strawberry cream cheese..."

Kerron Scott

"Best breakfast around coffee great service..."

Fred Dorski

"I love the sandwiches there and the people are friendly! Great place to eat for..."

Jennifer Bennett

"Man what an awesome place they change the place up but definitely for the better I will be going here instead of any other place thanks..."

Quincy Zabroski

"Best bagels in town. Marie makes the best porkroll..."

Joann Hoopengardner

"I had the pleasure of meeting Michelle and the whole crew here at Oh What A Bagel and I must say they are all amazing AND the bagels are ... GREAT..."

Charles Nicastro

"The absolute BEST BAGELS around!!! Love the place. Michelle is..."

Ken Gerb

"GREAT BAGELS. If you know bagels, this place doesn't disapoint. If you think Wawa has bagels... then I don't know what to say other than GET HERE..."

Stuck Up Sticker Company

"Everytime I've gone there the bagels have been great.. It's a weekly stop for me and will continue to..."

Angelo Hayton

"This place has the best bagels and breakfast sandwiches. I come here at least a few times a week. This place has been here for a long time which is..."

james huang

"These are best bagels I’ve ever eaten! The cream cheese has perfect taste and texture. I’m a loyal customer of Oh What a Bagel, right here in..."

Shannon Norfolk

"Delicious fresh bagels. Super soft. Yummy sandwiches made to..."

Sharon Foca

Baskin-robbins

"Ice cream is always a good..."

Andrew Costa presents Drew's backyard adventures

"The donuts are mm..."

Rosa Montes Ponce

Gerald Smith

Carlos Acevedo

David Parada

Shady Rest Restaurant

80/100 (1108 ratings)

"Another Great Meal, and Paul, our server, rocked....an employee who really takes pride in his work..my check number is 2564 table 13/1. Thanks again..."

Tom Coccia

"Shady Rest is our home away from home place to go. I have never had a bad meal. The food is as fresh as you can get. Everything is homemade. The..."

Susan Kocak

"One of my top favorite restaurants. Love the neighborhood cozy vibe. Food is ALWAYS amazing (krabby bread and steak alexis �) and service is always..."

Tracy Pelose

"best chicken franchese ever.its so good the leftovers are just as good the next day and it's so good I'd eat it for dessert lol. I can't order it..."

Corey Lynch

"I have traveled a few states, in this here, United States, hands down, I've yet to find a restaurant with menu you can order anything, and be..."

Christine Virgil

"I can't believe I've never been here before. Great food, the place is adorable and our waitress was awesome. We will definitely be back. Probably a..."

Karen Hamilton Cavell

"We have heard about this pizza for years and today we decided to try it !! Loved it and the friendly staff !! Thank you Dan for your hospitality..."

Nancy Sweeney Mullins

"Went for first time tonight. Bartender was friendly and made a great martini, place is really cute and unique. Nice selection. Had chicken..."

Marie Mccauley

"Delicious and abundant food! The staff is pretty awesome as well.. Definitely hasnt changed much since they opened in the 60's and thats a good..."

John Boronkas

"Great food and excellent service. Celebrated St. Patty's Day there because Irish restaurants were too packed. Found this gem with my son's first St...."

Adam Berkowitz

"Very good food and a neat ambience. The restaurant has a lot of character and we are always satisfied after eating there. Steak Alexis is..."

Rich Kozlowski

"Tried Shady Rest from a recommendation. Delicious! I’ve only ordered their lobster bisque & steaks, but WOW! Steaks are on the level of..."

Lisa R

"If you love burgers, you have to try their burgers. The blue cheese, mushroom and onion burger is to die for. Juicy meat and cooked medium..."

Patricia Cimino

"Love the people that work here. I never go to bars but this one I can’t stay away from. Not only great people, but great food too! (Especially the..."

Meagan Francis

"The best wings I've ever had and incredible service!! Our waitress was amazing and entertaining. Never had a bad meal here..."

Aj DeLucia

"Love this place! Always a good service and awesome food. Acme Cuban sandwich is my..."

Mariusz Bulc

"My favorite place to go for lunch for bite and a beer on my day..."

Christopher Paul

"Only there for a few beers and small lunch, tap beer was cold, and I had soup and Salida, beef soup very good, as was the..."

Lou Avezzano

"Cool joint,good food at a reasonable price and a lot of it! Craft beer,pint..."

Rye Tippett

"We go there quite often. Food is always great and service is excellent. Donna is the best by..."

Laurie Nigota-Robinson

"I go often when I take my mom to shoprite the waitresses are always so friendly food is delishes .had a crab cake sandwich yesterday it was..."

Patricia K Mikell Simpson

"Great atmosphere, the food is delicious especially their chili, white pies and burgers! Great servers too, all attentive and smiling all the time...."

Christopher Casole

"The muscles are outstanding and Andrea the bartender is so friendly and always makes u feel so..."

Michele Kunze

"Prices are good. People are good. The music is usually good on the nights they have it. They have a large assortment of beers. That's great if you're..."

Karen Ricotta

"Favorite place for my wife and I, great servers, if you like crispy wings, ask for them to be put back on the grill after - they're incredible. The..."

William Ellis

"Great local spot if you don't feel like driving all over looking for a drink and something to eat. The menu has a variety of choices. Burgers are..."

Francisco Lopez

"Awesome place. Live music. Craft beers. Good vibes. Delicious food. Staff are some of the nicest, most attentive & accommodating servers i have..."

erica flooding

"No idea what's up with all of the negative reviews. I've been here multiple times over the past couple of years and I've never had a bad meal here!..."

Brian Hickey

Bubbakoo's Burritos

Wheelchair Accessible

"They cleaned up the dining room for more room. Great idea fast service and food was hot and good. Fresh food very friendly staff.will attended..."

Donald Tumminelli

"Bayville Bubbakoo's very clean courteous stuff over all my experience was excellent. Lulu was very courteous polite and completed my order to my..."

Barbara Lee

"Amazing staff! The manager at this location is by far the best. Corporate is lucky to have her! Great job ! The Uber Eats guy. Thank..."

king Ed

"Took the girls To lunch gotta say I was so impressed with the improvements. Food fresh place super clean big meals for the price Staff super..."

Kim Morris

Twin Harbors Restaurant

Wheelchair Accessible

"Small, intimate venue just off the beaten track in Bayville. The atmosphere is upscale and the sea scallops are a winner, either sauted or broiled...."

Jim Boniello

"Always enjoy the food. I am mostly homebound and the Peterson"s are very reasonable, take out orders are ready on time and we never have to check the..."

Deidre Mccarthy

"Solid seafood & and comfort food joint with a lovely old school vibe in Bayville. My wife always gets the sole, I get a chicken dish or a special......"

Robert Moore

"My wife and I have dined at Twin Harbors for decades and the restaurant's fare never disappoints. If you enjoy fresh seafood you can't miss here. Be..."

Philip Minicozzi

"This small hidden gem in Bayville is located right before Wall's Warf restaurant and Kurt it's proprietor is ready to receive you warmly upon..."

Edward Rodriguez

"We had the best food and service here about two weeks ago, that we are still talking about it and are looking forward to our next visit. Hopefully..."

Abby Brosnan

"I've been going to Twin Harbors for over 30 years. Always consistent, always a great meal at a fair price. The seafood is always fresh, prepared..."

Michael Martino

"Excellent food and super service. I highly recommend this wonderful location because of the quality and the wonderful atmosphere. Odd thing was..."

Michael Richtberg

"Awesome food great service, friendly staff and the owner took time to make me feel at home I can’t wait to bring my wife over to eat here , I will..."

Daniel Morcilio

"A very friendly place with great Service and excellent food. My family and I have been going there for 48 plus years!! Dane is a great bar..."

peter trinche

"Excellent food, service and prices! Always a great meal! The drinks are STIFF too!..."

nancy muth

"This spot simply knows how to please their customers. Always with a helpful demeanor. The food is conveniently priced, always flavorful and..."

jose garcia

"The best burgers and seafood in town friendly atmosphere and home made desserts highly..."

Michael Benny

Wall's Wharf

76/100 (1740 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"What can be said about the absolutely beautiful and perfect location of this one-of-a-kind (seasonal) outdoor on the beach seating, having dinner as..."

Lee Gee

"Do yourself a favor and just order the firecracker shrimp to start with the Lobster Roll for your entree. There’s nothing else you need to get..."

Sean Johnson

"Great sceneries, good food and services. Enjoy coming here several times a year with friends and..."

Insoo Om

"Really enjoyed my time here. Food and drinks were on point, service was excellent, and nothing beats spending time at the beach so yeah. You should..."

jorge lam ki

"A wonderful place to dine - quiet and on the beach. I will warn you it is on the pricey side - but worth it for the food. Servers are sweet and the..."

K B

"The atmosphere ALONE makes me want to go over and over and over again. It was a beautiful day. The service was EXCELLENT. The attention provided to..."

Tamika Walker

"We really liked this placed! The food was better than we were expecting, good portions and good flavor. the staff was very professional: after giving..."

Virginia Tsai

"Wow do we love Walls Wharf! We’ve always loved this restaurant, so we decided to have our wedding here and it was absolutely perfect! Frank, the..."

Danielle Bissonette

"This was a very nice surprise! With some time to spare, we took a drive to Bayville and Centre Island -- nice views of the water, and we noticed the..."

Michael Ciccone

"This is such a fun beach eating experience! Giselle, our server (several times), is awesome! She has taken good care of us and is very attentive. The..."

Loretta Eldridge

Martell’s Waters Edge

71/100 (1315 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

Mj's Restaurant Bar & Grill

70/100 (1098 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"It was a good choice! My wife really liked fish and chips: very little bread over fish, fish was fresh and just melting in your mouth. My burger was..."

Igor Krasnoperov

"We were sitting in the bar, it was a weekday , so not a lot of people's ,not really hot outside. I like service, great food,and great drinks. ..."

Tatiana Panova

"The food is overpriced imo, but the staff was very accommodating and friendly. The atmosphere was pleasant and the food is good. Not a big menu by..."

Tara (Tara)

"Nice lunch spot/Tiki bar across the street from Oyster Bay and connected to Bayville Amusement Park. Good burgers, salads, fish sandwiches, entrees..."

Nick Ferrara

"Awesome atmosphere with great food and drinks. You get to enjoy a well served meal with the views of the..."

Marcin Cieslak

"The food is just as good as the views... Which are AMAZING! You can see the ocean from your table. Service is excellent. I love the roof deck with..."

Penny Fisher

"Been here twice both were very good experiences. I saw a beautiful fish tank but not the second time I went.Food was delicious. Saw Billy Joel here..."

Robert Fitzpatrick

"Incredible place for drinks on the water! First of all, the view is gorgeous and beautiful in every way, definitely come to the rooftop if you can..."

AndiamoAdventure

"Really nicely decorated for Christmas time and themed cocktails that were well priced. If I was in the area I would go back..."

Coralie Pattenden

"Great food! Awesome and friendly..."

Marc Rudon

"Service was great. Food was delicious. One of the items I would NOT recommend is any type of burger. It had absolutely no flavor. My girlfriend..."

Jonathan Robles

Breakers Sports Bar And Grill

Reset

There are 20 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

American cuisine: the best places to taste it in Bayville

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Ann Ewart

Tara Kennedy

Carrie Ann Leotis

Bob Runyon

Ian J. McAndrew

Valerie Lembo Bello

Amanda Rinderer

Stacy Bell

Jessica Jones Jablonski

Dennis Lotter

Tera Meahan

Tisha Milo Breslow

Chrissy Brown

Shelly MacLallen

Jaime Bell

Danielle Rose

Kristin Preece

Heather From-Bieber

Patricia Kennedy Herflicker

Donna Milley

Danielle Petriello-Mezera

Anthony Mignano

peter torregrossa

Mark Brennan

Matt harootunian

Edward Laszkow

Lisa Richichi

David Spatola

Maria Vernachio

Brandon Ruland

Jamie Schaefer

Sofie Nicole

Theresa Lowe-Syers

Dora Pap

Ellen Fine Labate

Anthony Budney

Marcile Narey Alesi

Maha Malik

Crystal Capellan

Patrick Fogarty

Colby Joseph

Kristi R

Joanne Race

pamoouru

Tim Caputo

Danielle Pacicca

Brandon Bares

Monica Mero

Alfred Torres

Carmine Cannizzaro

Cliff Russo

LAURA M

Brqwerty

Lewis Dolin

abey philip

B. Griffin Armstrong

Lisa Fisher

Jessica Geneski

Laura Cienkowski

Joan Essex

Alan Miller

David Wright

Trish Elizabeth Neill

Frank Napoli

Celeste C Pacifico

Sal Verdi

James Kamerer

Kay Charon