Main St Pizza Company

First time diners at this restaurant, but it won't be the last. Honestly, the 2nd best pizza I've ever had and I've been all over the U.S. We ordered a special promotion of a speciality pizza that includes bread sticks, salad, and beverage. We order the Godfather of pepperoni, sausage, prosciutto, banana peppers, and cheese. Bread sticks were coated in a special seasoning then covered in mozzarella and the dipping sauce was a nice sweet/savory blend. The pizza was flawless, cooked to perfection with nice outer crunch and chewy inside. No skimping on the toppings, hence the 5-star rating. My new favorite go-to for pizza!

Don't let the name "Main Street Pizza Company" fool you. Chose your atmosphere from outside dinning to indoor family dinning to even a dimmer intimate dinning area to experience. To go orders cleverly pick up thru a separate entrance, not to disturb diners. The staff is amazing! The hostess sat us immediately. Our waitress, Kaylee, is an absolute charm with experience and a sweet personality. She made us feel so comfortable. We ordered Manicotti and Rigatoni Bolognese. The homemade sauces are the best we've ever tasted. We watched a 16 oz. meatball order deliver to another table and immediately asked Kaylee to add one to our order. Great move! The grapefruit sized meatball is the BEST EVER! Romantic and classy restaurant hiding on the Main. Great for the gang, family, friends, or a romantic date night. <3

Where do I start? Batavia food epic fail!!!!!! They said an hour wait and the food was absolutely cold. The chicken wings were huge like they had been individually injected with hormones, freezer burnt, Covered in feathers, with a piece of white bread at the bottom of the chicken wings, soaked in oil. The pizza… This was supposed to be I guess a margarita pizza. All I can say is yuck yuck 🤮 🤮 . It was grilled bread with cold cheese and a jar of tomato sauce. I tried to be optimistic about these restaurants in Batavia but 20 thumbs down!!!! Needless to say if I can give -0 stars I would and I will never ever ever return. I’m scratching my head on how these people got four stars. Grade FFFFFFFFFFFF. Please don’t respond with a generic comment. The food was absolutely disgusting and there is no excuse!!!!!!!!!