The baked goods at this place are insanely delicious. The sugar cookies and shortbread cookies were the best I've ever tasted. Ever. The cupcakes and the icing were very moist and delicious. No hard icing here. The scones were crumbly yet not dried out. Exactly what a scone should taste like. The lemon squares were amazing!! I couldn't have made them better myself and I am a baker. Not dried out at all, and perfect taste of lemony tart and sweet.
This place is so good. I have been many times and the desserts are always good. Red velvet is good, apple pie is good. Can't go wrong here. Cookies are good too. Wide variety.
Acceso gratis a wifi. Buen cafe y la ensaladas muy buenas.
Los pasteles son muy grandes . Falta un 1/2 porcion .
La terraza en el verano es agradable .
We... got a kick out of all their creative flavors (I counted 41 varieties on their menu, and spotted about 30 in the display case)...Each frosting/topping was creamy...The cakes were...crumbly soft…
If you're looking for a place for dessert, want a cheesecake or a special cake for a special occasion, Sugar Shack is THE place in the ATL to find it. I confess! I have a sweet tooth and believe that every good meal ends with dessert but seldom do we have
Small place of 5-6 tables. They also serve sandwiches and soup dujour. Mini pecan pie is not too sweet full of pecans. If the other place has a long wait then come here for a cup of joe.
Its conveniently located on Peachtree Road and Brookhaven Drive across from Brookhaven Marta station.
Kelly “KellyDidItAgain” Marsh
+5
I love this place- but who does not like sugar? I have bought sandwiches for my open houses from here before and they were always a hit.
I have taken clients there when we needed a place in Brookhaven to sit and talk, and they always find something nice to drink or munch on.
One of the main things that makes this place unique is the gluten free cupcakes. Usually they have one choice of a gluten free cupcake, and this past time I went they had a chocolate and a vanilla option. It is hard to find delicious options if you can't eat wheat, so I highly recommend this place if you need a sweet alternative!
I did not want you to forget that this place is perfect for lunch if you are looking for something pretty quick and fresh.
Cute place for sweets and breakfast/lunch. The cupcakes and muffins are not super moist but will definitely be back to try other snacks/treats! Menu options sound tasty!
Best cupcakes in Brookhaven. So many flavors to choose from so many ways to be bad! And their sandwiches are super delicious!
We were the customers who came I 10 minutes before closing but the guys were super friendly! Cant wait to eat my cupcake and lemon bar!
I am a baker, and these baked goods are what baked goods are supposed to taste like. Anyone who says the cupcakes are mediocre doesn't know what a cupcake is supposed to taste like. They have flavor, are moist, the icing isn't hard. The sugar cookies and the shortbread cookies were the best I have ever tasted. Ever. They were super buttery and soft. The lemon square was insanely moist and delicious. The scones were crumbly yet moist. Love this place!!!!
Awesome desserts! Glad we found this place while in Atlanta.
This place was super cute. They have a wide variety of desserts, coffee and food. The server was very nice and helpful. The cupcakes were just okay, but I'd go back to try other things in their menu.
Let me start by saying: YUM! I am very critical of my desserts, i have a huge sweet tooth. This place exceeded my expectations. It's at a great location with a bunch of parking, the prices are so great, and the sweets were so good. I got a lemon cupcake and a traditional vanilla. The cake itself wasn't anything spectacular, but the icing was TO DIE for.
I ordered a whole Red Velvet Cheesecake. Oh my goodness. I can't describe how good this thing tasted. The first time I had it was actually and one of their sister restaurants Einsteins in Midtown. This cheesecake is so luscious and almost organic.
The chocolate mixed with the red velvet cake are a winner in my book. The cake comes in a nice hard box. Not flimsy. It also comes indented with marks so you know where to slice it evenly. Wet the knife between slicing to keep the cut clean.
This dessert is heaven and will shine in anyone's dinner table or office party. I purchased it for my team at Thanksgiving and everyone raved about it. I will probably purchase another one for Christmas.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Atlanta
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes