Fat Girlz Bakin

Stopped by for the Turtle cupcakes and just grabbed a 6 variety of what was left at the end of day. WOW! I am so glad I did! The blueberry pancake cupcake shocked me by how amazing it was. I am not saying that my opinion is the right one BUT I eat and bake more than my fair share of cupcakes. My husband claimed that my Turtle cupcake was better (of course, it is catered to our preferences) but all of the Fat Girlz cupcakes surprised and impressed me. They are a wonderful treat of sweetness, without being too sweet with incredible frosting that does not at all taste like Crisco or making you want a glass of water right after consuming. Cupcakes are a very personal preference but these are AMAZING and worth a try. I suggest trying ones you might not even be interested in... you might find a brand new favorite!!!!

I love Fat Girlz, I'm so lucky to work across the street. She's such a great person and I know that the reviews say that's "she's never open" well she's a one person business.........that's the perks of being in business for yourself. You set your own hours. She does have Saturdays open so if you can't get one during the week then go on Saturday! She's super nice and I love that she has those punch cards to get a free cupcake. The flavors are just out of this world! Some of the best cupcakes I ever had where from this little gem in the city of Appleton. Where else can you get a Strawberry Margarita cupcake or a rootbeer float cupake??? She is far better in presentation than her competitors.

Very disappointed. We booked Lynnae to do our wedding almost a year in advance. She acted very excited to do it, as it was a Halloween themed wedding, and she talked about decorating our cupcakes with Halloween themed sprinkles. When the day came, none of our cupcakes had those sprinkles on them and they were very boring looking. They didn't fit with our theme at all. She also for some reason decided to book another event on the same day as our wedding, so she came and put the cupcakes out at 2 o'clock in the afternoon. Guests didn't even arrive for appetizers until 430!!! Cupcakes absolutely should not have been out during appetizers, and I was ticked when I found that out. People were eating our cupcakes before they even had dinner!!! For some reason she insisted on putting the cupcakes out herself, when we very well could've had our wedding planner put them out at our venue at a more reasonable time! I did not want those cupcakes out before dinner. She was very uncooperative and thought that her way was better for everything. She debated us about the frosting colors that we wanted and clearly didn't listen to our requests. I would never ever go to her again.

I've been trying for over a year to try this place. Every time I make an attempt the place is either closed when I get there (with in her business hours) or she posts on Facebook about a closure. There's always an event or other excuse. These cupcakes must be made out of gold. I can't imagine how this place has stayed in business for over a year if its never open. I now drive 40 minutes down to Tamara's in Oshkosh. She has set hours, two locations, and never runs out of cupcakes.